← Back to scan
File as GitHub Issue repo: ai-dynamo/nixl

Push this scan report to ai-dynamo/nixl

Click the green button below to open GitHub’s new-issue form, pre-filled with the report title, summary table, top findings, and an embedded score-card image. No authentication needed — you review on GitHub before submitting. Repobility is credited as the scanner.

Embedded score card image

This image will render at the top of the issue body. Hosted on Repobility, refreshes automatically after re-scans.

Repobility score card

Issue title

Detected a Generic API Key, potentially exposing access to various services and sensitive

Curate findings to include

Pick exactly which findings appear in the issue body. By default the top 5 are included. Uncheck noise, check what matters.

Top 5 (default)
Severity Rule Title File:line
CRIT MINED030 [MINED030] Python Pickle Loads: pickle.loads() can execute arbitrary code via __reduce__. benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:178
CRIT MINED018 [MINED018] Unsafe Deserialization Pickle: pickle.loads / yaml.load (without Loader=SafeLo… benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:178
CRIT SEC081 [SEC081] Python: pickle.loads / marshal.loads on untrusted data: pickle.load(s) and marsh… benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:178
CRIT generic-api-key Detected a Generic API Key, potentially exposing access to various services and sensitive… src/plugins/azure_blob/README.md:143
CRIT generic-api-key Detected a Generic API Key, potentially exposing access to various services and sensitive… src/plugins/azure_blob/README.md:134
CRIT generic-api-key Detected a Generic API Key, potentially exposing access to various services and sensitive… src/plugins/azure_blob/README.md:127
CRIT generic-api-key Detected a Generic API Key, potentially exposing access to various services and sensitive… benchmark/nixlbench/README.md:878
CRIT generic-api-key Detected a Generic API Key, potentially exposing access to various services and sensitive… benchmark/nixlbench/README.md:861
CRIT MINED125 GHA script injection via github.event.pull_request.head.ref in run-step .github/workflows/build_validation.yml:40
HIGH SEC029 [SEC029] Server-Side Request Forgery (SSRF) — outbound HTTP from user input: Outbound HTT… src/plugins/azure_blob/azure_blob_clien…:38
HIGH MINED003 [MINED003] Rust Unwrap In Prod: .unwrap() panics if None/Err. Acceptable in tests; risky … src/bindings/rust/src/descriptors/xfer.…:193
HIGH MINED003 [MINED003] Rust Unwrap In Prod: .unwrap() panics if None/Err. Acceptable in tests; risky … src/bindings/rust/src/descriptors.rs:69
HIGH MINED003 [MINED003] Rust Unwrap In Prod: .unwrap() panics if None/Err. Acceptable in tests; risky … src/bindings/rust/build.rs:162
HIGH SEC128 [SEC128] Async function without await — fire-and-forget Promise (AI mistake): Async call … benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:208
HIGH SEC113 [SEC113] SSH host-key verification disabled (MITM): Accepting any SSH host key on first c… .ci/scripts/stop_slurm_allocation.sh:115
HIGH SEC113 [SEC113] SSH host-key verification disabled (MITM): Accepting any SSH host key on first c… .ci/scripts/run_tests_slurm.sh:129
HIGH SEC113 [SEC113] SSH host-key verification disabled (MITM): Accepting any SSH host key on first c… .ci/scripts/run_slurm_allocation.sh:181
HIGH MINED108 `self._params` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/commands/nixlbench.py:485
HIGH MINED108 `self._params` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/commands/nixlbench.py:445
HIGH MINED108 `self._configure_obj` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/commands/nixlbench.py:267
HIGH MINED108 `self._configure_ucx` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/commands/nixlbench.py:265
HIGH MINED108 `self._configure_posix` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/commands/nixlbench.py:263
HIGH MINED108 `self._configure_gds` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/commands/nixlbench.py:261
HIGH MINED108 `self.barrier` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:209
HIGH MINED108 `self.barrier` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:205
HIGH MINED108 `self.barrier` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:193
HIGH MINED108 `self.barrier` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:186
HIGH MINED108 `self._get_int_val` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:147
HIGH MINED108 `self._get_group_id` used but never assigned in __init__ benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:110
HIGH COMP001 [COMP001] High cognitive complexity: Function `update` has cognitive complexity 28 (Sonar… benchmark/kvbench/models/model_config.py:146
HIGH DKR014 Dockerfile copies the entire context without .dockerignore contrib/Dockerfile.vllm:20
HIGH DKR014 Dockerfile copies the entire context without .dockerignore contrib/Dockerfile.sglang:20
HIGH DKR014 Dockerfile copies the entire context without .dockerignore contrib/Dockerfile.manylinux:321
HIGH DKR014 Dockerfile copies the entire context without .dockerignore contrib/Dockerfile:258
HIGH DKR014 Dockerfile copies the entire context without .dockerignore benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:252
HIGH DKR014 Dockerfile copies the entire context without .dockerignore benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:251
HIGH DKR014 Dockerfile copies the entire context without .dockerignore benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:84
HIGH DKR006 Dockerfile pipes a remote script into a shell benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:73
HIGH DKR014 Dockerfile copies the entire context without .dockerignore .ci/dockerfiles/Dockerfile.gpu-test:27
HIGH DKR006 Dockerfile pipes a remote script into a shell .ci/dockerfiles/Dockerfile.build_helper:33
HIGH MINED115 Action `actions/checkout` pinned to mutable ref `@v3` .github/workflows/clang-format.yml:9
HIGH MINED115 Action `pre-commit/action` pinned to mutable ref `@v3.0.0` .github/workflows/pre-commit.yml:16
HIGH MINED115 Action `actions/setup-python` pinned to mutable ref `@v3` .github/workflows/pre-commit.yml:15
HIGH MINED115 Action `actions/checkout` pinned to mutable ref `@v3` .github/workflows/pre-commit.yml:9
HIGH MINED115 Action `actions/checkout` pinned to mutable ref `@v4` .github/workflows/build_validation.yml:16
HIGH MINED126 Workflow container/services image `ghcr.io/ai-dynamo/dynamo/helm-tester:0.1.1` unpinned .github/workflows/copyright-checks.yml:10
HIGH MINED115 Action `actions/checkout` pinned to mutable ref `@v4` .github/workflows/copyright-checks.yml:18
HIGH MINED115 Action `actions/checkout` pinned to mutable ref `@v4` .github/workflows/aws_efa_validation.yml:23
HIGH MINED115 Action `actions/github-script` pinned to mutable ref `@v7` .github/workflows/external_contributor.…:48
HIGH MINED115 Action `actions/github-script` pinned to mutable ref `@v7` .github/workflows/external_contributor.…:30
HIGH MINED115 Action `actions/checkout` pinned to mutable ref `@v3` .github/workflows/pr-size-check.yml:10
HIGH MINED115 Action `NVIDIA/blossom-action` pinned to mutable ref `@main` .github/workflows/blossom-ci.yml:53
HIGH MINED115 Action `actions/checkout` pinned to mutable ref `@v2` .github/workflows/blossom-ci.yml:46
HIGH MINED115 Action `actions/checkout` pinned to mutable ref `@v3` .github/workflows/python-checks.yml:16
HIGH MINED118 Dockerfile FROM `gcr.io/google.com/cloudsdktool/cloud-sdk:alpine` not pinned by digest .ci/dockerfiles/Dockerfile.infinia-libs:23
HIGH MINED131 pre-commit hook `https://github.com/pre-commit/pre-commit-hooks` pinned to mutable rev `v… .pre-commit-config.yaml:48
HIGH MINED131 pre-commit hook `https://github.com/codespell-project/codespell` pinned to mutable rev `v… .pre-commit-config.yaml:41
HIGH MINED131 pre-commit hook `https://github.com/PyCQA/flake8` pinned to mutable rev `7.1.2` .pre-commit-config.yaml:34
HIGH MINED131 pre-commit hook `https://github.com/psf/black` pinned to mutable rev `24.10.0` .pre-commit-config.yaml:28
HIGH MINED131 pre-commit hook `https://github.com/timothycrosley/isort` pinned to mutable rev `5.12.0` .pre-commit-config.yaml:22
HIGH MINED131 pre-commit hook `https://github.com/pre-commit/mirrors-mypy` pinned to mutable rev `v1.14… .pre-commit-config.yaml:16
HIGH RUSTSEC-2025-0055 tracing-subscriber: RUSTSEC-2025-0055 examples/rust/Cargo.lock
HIGH RUSTSEC-2026-0007 bytes: RUSTSEC-2026-0007 examples/rust/Cargo.lock
HIGH RUSTSEC-2025-0141 bincode: RUSTSEC-2025-0141 Cargo.lock
MED SEC007 [SEC007] Unsafe Deserialization: Unsafe deserialization can execute arbitrary code. benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:178
MED SEC127 [SEC127] AI agent stub — TODO: implement / pass placeholder body: Function body left as T… benchmark/kvbench/models/models.py:74
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `send_partial_agent_metadata` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:873
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `get_partial_agent_metadata` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:812
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `check_remote_xfer_done` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:749
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `update_notifs` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:730
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `get_new_notifs` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:716
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `initialize_xfer` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:599
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `make_prepped_xfer` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:552
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `prep_xfer_dlist` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:495
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `make_connection` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:466
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `deregister_memory` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:425
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `register_memory` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:402
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `create_backend` (dict) src/api/python/_api.py:382
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `__init__` (list) src/api/python/_api.py:150
MED MINED109 Mutable default argument in `execute_transfer` (list) examples/python/remote_storage_example/…:31
MED MINED111 Bare except continues silently benchmark/kvbench/main.py:192
MED COMP001 [COMP001] High cognitive complexity: Function `all_reduce` has cognitive complexity 16 (S… benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:202
MED COMP001 [COMP001] High cognitive complexity: Function `barrier` has cognitive complexity 19 (Sona… benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:99
MED DKR017 Dockerfile installs dependencies after copying the full source tree contrib/Dockerfile:291
MED DKR007 Docker build context has no .dockerignore .dockerignore
MED MINED124 requirements.txt: `types-PyYAML` has no version pin requirements.txt:25
MED MINED124 requirements.txt: `tomli` has no version pin requirements.txt:24
MED MINED124 requirements.txt: `toml` has no version pin requirements.txt:23
MED MINED124 requirements.txt: `pyyaml` has no version pin requirements.txt:22
MED MINED124 requirements.txt: `pytest` has no version pin requirements.txt:21
MED MINED124 requirements.txt: `pre-commit` has no version pin requirements.txt:20
MED MINED124 requirements.txt: `mypy` has no version pin requirements.txt:19
MED MINED124 requirements.txt: `isort` has no version pin requirements.txt:18
MED MINED124 requirements.txt: `flake8` has no version pin requirements.txt:17
MED MINED124 requirements.txt: `black` has no version pin requirements.txt:16
MED DKR009 Dockerfile separates apt update from install benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:64
MED DKR009 Dockerfile separates apt update from install benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:29
MED DKR001 Docker final stage has no non-root USER contrib/Dockerfile.vllm:17
MED DKR001 Docker final stage has no non-root USER contrib/Dockerfile.sglang:17
MED DKR001 Docker final stage has no non-root USER contrib/Dockerfile.manylinux:19
MED DKR001 Docker final stage has no non-root USER contrib/Dockerfile:20
MED DKR001 Docker final stage has no non-root USER benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:109
MED DKR001 Docker final stage has no non-root USER .ci/dockerfiles/Dockerfile.infinia-libs:24
MED DKR001 Docker final stage has no non-root USER .ci/dockerfiles/Dockerfile.gpu-test:11
MED AGT015 Remote install command pipes network code directly to a shell src/bindings/rust/README.md:10
MED AGT015 Remote install command pipes network code directly to a shell README.md:226
LOW SEC132 [SEC132] String concat where the language has interpolation (AI style drift): String buil… examples/cpp/nixl_example.cpp:121
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/unit/plugins/ucx/ucx_backend_test.…:17
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/unit/plugins/posix/nixl_posix_test…:117
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/unit/plugins/posix/nixl_posix_test…:56
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/unit/plugins/object/nixl_object_te…:166
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/unit/plugins/object/nixl_object_te…:11
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/unit/plugins/object/nixl_object_te…:2
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/unit/plugins/infinia/infinia_nixl_…:213
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/unit/plugins/infinia/infinia_nixl_…:90
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/unit/plugins/hf3fs/nixl_hf3fs_test…:57
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/unit/plugins/gds_mt/nixl_gds_mt_te…:29
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/gtest/plugins/uccl/uccl_test.cpp:79
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/gtest/plugins/obj_plugin.cpp:53
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files test/gtest/plugins/obj_cuobj_plugin.cpp:59
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/plugins/ucx/ucx_backend.h:58
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/plugins/ucx/ucx_backend.h:44
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/plugins/uccl/uccl_backend.h:14
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/plugins/uccl/uccl_backend.h:7
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/plugins/posix/posix_backend.h:45
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/plugins/posix/posix_aio_io_queue.cpp:12
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/plugins/posix/linux_aio_io_queue.cpp:10
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/plugins/libfabric/libfabric_backend…:226
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/plugins/libfabric/libfabric_backend…:185
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/plugins/gpunetio/gpunetio_backend.h:70
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/bindings/rust/src/utils/string_list…:55
LOW AIC003 Duplicated implementation block across source files src/bindings/rust/src/descriptors/xfer.…:72
LOW DKR010 Dockerfile leaves apt package indexes in the image layer contrib/Dockerfile:263
LOW DKR010 Dockerfile leaves apt package indexes in the image layer contrib/Dockerfile:74
LOW DKR010 Dockerfile leaves apt package indexes in the image layer contrib/Dockerfile:43
LOW DKR010 Dockerfile leaves apt package indexes in the image layer benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:205
LOW DKR010 Dockerfile leaves apt package indexes in the image layer benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:195
LOW DKR010 Dockerfile leaves apt package indexes in the image layer benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:86
LOW DKR010 Dockerfile leaves apt package indexes in the image layer benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:53
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache contrib/Dockerfile.vllm:22
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache contrib/Dockerfile.manylinux:295
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache contrib/Dockerfile.manylinux:292
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache contrib/Dockerfile.manylinux:290
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache contrib/Dockerfile:306
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache contrib/Dockerfile:255
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache contrib/Dockerfile:252
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache contrib/Dockerfile:250
LOW DKR011 Dockerfile installs recommended OS packages contrib/Dockerfile:43
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:290
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:267
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:249
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:245
LOW DKR012 Dockerfile keeps pip download cache benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:243
LOW DKR011 Dockerfile installs recommended OS packages benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:205
LOW DKR011 Dockerfile installs recommended OS packages benchmark/nixlbench/contrib/Dockerfile:195
LOW DKR011 Dockerfile installs recommended OS packages .ci/dockerfiles/Dockerfile.build_helper:27
LOW DKR011 Dockerfile installs recommended OS packages .ci/dockerfiles/Dockerfile.base:36
INFO MINED066 [MINED066] Rust Panic Macro: panic!() unwinds the stack. Use Result for recoverable error… src/bindings/rust/build.rs:64
INFO MINED059 [MINED059] Rust Expect In Prod: .expect(...) panics same as unwrap with a custom message. src/bindings/rust/src/utils/params.rs:108
INFO MINED059 [MINED059] Rust Expect In Prod: .expect(...) panics same as unwrap with a custom message. src/bindings/rust/build.rs:234
INFO MINED068 [MINED068] Rust Unsafe Block: unsafe { ... } block. Compiler safety guarantees disabled i… src/bindings/rust/src/descriptors/query…:34
INFO MINED068 [MINED068] Rust Unsafe Block: unsafe { ... } block. Compiler safety guarantees disabled i… src/bindings/rust/src/descriptors.rs:58
INFO MINED068 [MINED068] Rust Unsafe Block: unsafe { ... } block. Compiler safety guarantees disabled i… examples/rust/src/single_process_exampl…:81
INFO MINED075 [MINED075] C Malloc No Check: malloc/calloc/realloc return value used without checking fo… examples/cpp/nixl_example.cpp:146
INFO MINED042 [MINED042] Cpp New Without Delete: C++ raw new without RAII / unique_ptr — memory leak ri… src/api/cpp/backend/backend_plugin.h:96
INFO MINED042 [MINED042] Cpp New Without Delete: C++ raw new without RAII / unique_ptr — memory leak ri… benchmark/nixlbench/src/worker/worker.c…:91
INFO MINED042 [MINED042] Cpp New Without Delete: C++ raw new without RAII / unique_ptr — memory leak ri… benchmark/nixlbench/src/runtime/etcd/py…:32
INFO MINED043 [MINED043] Http Not Https: Hardcoded http:// (not localhost) for endpoints that handle cr… examples/device/ep/scripts/reset_etcd.sh:23
INFO MINED043 [MINED043] Http Not Https: Hardcoded http:// (not localhost) for endpoints that handle cr… benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:70
INFO MINED050 [MINED050] Stub Only Function: Function declared but body is just pass, return None, rais… benchmark/kvbench/runtime/rt_base.py:33
INFO MINED050 [MINED050] Stub Only Function: Function declared but body is just pass, return None, rais… benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:232
INFO MINED050 [MINED050] Stub Only Function: Function declared but body is just pass, return None, rais… benchmark/kvbench/models/models.py:43
INFO MINED063 [MINED063] Toctou Os Path Exists: if os.path.exists(p): open(p) — file can be replaced/de… benchmark/kvbench/models/model_config.py:123
INFO MINED062 [MINED062] Python Dataclass No Fields: @dataclass over an empty class — unfinished model. benchmark/kvbench/models/model_config.py:28
Reset to top 5 174 findings available (after auto-suppression of test files + won't-fix)

Issue body (markdown)

## Code-quality scan: `ai-dynamo/nixl`

**Score: 69/100 (C+)**  ·  200 findings  ·  scanned 2026-06-05 20:03 UTC  ·  87,355 LOC

| Severity | Count |
|---|---|
| CRITICAL | 9 |
| HIGH | 55 |
| MEDIUM | 42 |
| LOW | 51 |

📊 [Full filterable report](https://repobility.com/scan/53d6037f-ca55-47aa-82ef-91636bc47761/)  ·  ![scorecard](https://repobility.com/scan/53d6037f-ca55-47aa-82ef-91636bc47761/report.png?v=1780689803-s2)

### Top findings

1. **CRITICAL** `MINED030` — Python Pickle Loads
   `benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:178` · CWE-502 · ✓ Repobility
2. **CRITICAL** `MINED018` — Unsafe Deserialization Pickle
   `benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:178` · CWE-502 · ✓ Repobility
3. **CRITICAL** `SEC081` — Python: pickle.loads / marshal.loads on untrusted data
   `benchmark/kvbench/runtime/etcd_rt.py:178` · A05:2021 Security Misconfiguration
4. **CRITICAL** `generic-api-key` — Detected a Generic API Key, potentially exposing access to various services and sensitive 
   `src/plugins/azure_blob/README.md:143`
5. **CRITICAL** `generic-api-key` — Detected a Generic API Key, potentially exposing access to various services and sensitive 
   `src/plugins/azure_blob/README.md:134`

---

**Security note**: this issue is public. If any flagged finding is a real, exploitable vulnerability, please redirect to your `SECURITY.md` policy or open a [private security advisory](https://docs.github.com/en/code-security/security-advisories/guidance-on-reporting-and-writing-information-about-vulnerabilities/privately-reporting-a-security-vulnerability) instead. We're happy to close this and re-submit privately.

---

_Filed automatically. Close this issue if not useful — we won't refile. Full report: https://repobility.com/scan/53d6037f-ca55-47aa-82ef-91636bc47761/_
Already filed
This repo publishes a SECURITY.md policy and the scan contains 6 Critical/High security finding(s). Public issue filing would violate coordinated disclosure. Submit privately via the project's security reporting channel.
Megaproject â high spam risk
Could not determine 'ai-dynamo/nixl' star count (GitHub API rate-limited or unreachable). When in doubt about repo size, prefer opening a focused PR or a discussion rather than an issue.
Already filed
128/214 findings (60%) on this scan are already flagged as test-file, won't-fix, or suppressed. The scan is too noisy to file as a single issue. Curate down to specific actionable findings, or address the FP source first.

The button opens GitHubâs new-issue page in a new tab. You will see the title + body pre-filled â review, edit if you want, then click GitHubâs "Submit new issue" button. Repobility never posts anything on your behalf.

For real security findings on big repos: use the project's SECURITY.md or private advisory flow instead of a public issue.